'Outsourced' workers seek better deal in landmark case

'Outsourced' workers seek better deal…

A group of 75 workers, including porters and receptionists, are going to tribunal to gain more rights at work.
As outsourced employees, they are supplied to the University of London by a facilities company, but do not receive the same benefits as those employed directly.
The university does not accept it should be a "joint employer", which would allow for better entitlements.
The case could affect around 3.3 million outsourced workers in the UK.
Many big organisations pay facilities companies to provide workers who are often low paid, such as cleaners or security guards. This allows them to control the way people work, determining their pay and conditions, whilst avoiding many of the legal responsibilities of being an employer.

Making ends meet - Henry Chango Lopez is an outsourced worker at the heart of the campaign, which could become a game-changing legal challenge for millions of people around the country.
He works as a porter at the university, but is employed by the business services company Cordant, and has two jobs to make ends meet.
"I start my day at 4am," he said. "I travel from Hertfordshire to Southwark in London to do two hours cleaning work. Then I go straight to my main job as a porter at the University of London, where I work from 8am to 3pm."

Mr Lopez is part of the group, which also includes security guards and post-room staff, seeking a tribunal ruling that the university is recognised, along with Cordant, as their "joint employer".

The concept has existed in various forms for decades in the US. It allows outsourced or franchise employees in some circumstances to legally compel client companies or franchisors to enter into collective bargaining agreements. However, it has to be shown that these companies have sufficient "control" over the employees.

If established in the UK, unions could collectively bargain the pay, terms and conditions of outsourced workers with the "joint employer" - the employer that chooses to outsource. That employer may find it difficult to then justify inferior terms and conditions for its outsourced workers.

The workers are being supported by the Independent Workers Union of Great Britain. Its general secretary, Dr Jason Moyer-Lee, said: "For all intents and purposes, the outsourced workers at the University of London work for the university. It is the entity which essentially decides what their pay and terms and conditions are going to be.

"So, unless the workers can negotiate directly with the university, they can't really negotiate at all over their pay and terms and conditions."

'Enormous' impact - UK law has never recognised the concept of "joint employers" for the purpose of negotiating workers' terms and conditions.

Specialist employment lawyer Daphne Romney QC said that if it did, "it would be enormous". She added: "There would be about 3.3 million outsourced employees whose terms and conditions would improve because they would be on the same terms and conditions as the people they work alongside everyday but who are directly employed. And for the employers, of course, there would also be an impact because it would be more expensive to improve those terms and conditions."

Mr Lopez said his life would "change massively" if the principle was recognised, stopping him having to work two jobs and seeing a big improvement to his pension, but the university does not agree it is responsible.

In a statement, the University of London told the BBC: "The university does not employ any of these workers and does not accept that the relevant legislation recognises the concept of joint employment.  We have therefore not agreed to the Independent Workers Union of Great Britain's request for recognition."


A mature HR professional with over thirty years experience within the HR function both from a strategic and operational perspective, with over 18 years in senior management roles including those at…

Business Management

Working from Home - What Employers Need to Know

Who this article is for: Any employer with home working employees. How long this will take to read: 5 minutes (a medium…
Retail & Services

Wonderful price, wonderful service

SIM card deal via me. Just contact me if you're interested. 1. Unlimited minutes. 2. Unlimited texts. 3. Unlimited…
Business Management

What is a Business Health Check?

“Organisational health is the single greatest competitive advantage in any business.” Patrick Lencioni It is easy to…

More Articles

Retail & Services

How many countries use the POUND as currency?

Hello.  I hope this quiz question gets you thinking.  Anyone messages me with the correct answer before midnight this…
Business Management

Sitting comfortably while working from home

When you are working at home it is vital to make sure that you are sitting comfortably. Sitting on the wrong chair may…
Training and Development

8 Top Tips for increasing your engagement on LinkedIN

8Top Tips for increasing your engagement on your LinkedIn  Tip 1 Write-text only posts Write enough in your LinkedIn…

Would you like to promote an article ?

Post articles and opinions on Manchester Professionals to attract new clients and referrals. Feature in newsletters.
Join for free today and upload your articles for new contacts to read and enquire further.

Find the right professionals in Manchester

View The Full Index

Search By:

Submit your Enquiry here

Enquiry Details

Contact Details