Contract? What Contract? A Case Study

Contract? What Contract? A Case Study

I have previously written regarding contracts that we need to be very circumspect about what we put into a contract, because we do not have to go chapter and verse on clauses that will not bring any value to the contract or the relationship.

Novated Contracts: Don’t Let Sleeping Dogs Lie

Following that post, a new client’s Head of Procurement asked me to review their Telecommunications contract as they were short-handed and he read that we did this ad hoc service for customers. I gladly accepted and within the day I received the contract and before I could even fully read it and give my considered opinion, I found the following: 1) the contract was incomplete. It said it was 25 pages long, but I received 21 pages and no signature page. 2) the contracting parties did not include the name of our customer 3) Appendix C “Services” was not included. The HoP said they were thinking of taking the spend to market because their company had been getting a number of service failures and when they contacted the supplier’s customer services department, they were given the run around. The CFO had been stranded in Italy without reception and told the HoP to “SORT IT OUT” (yes, the CFO was shouting!)

My starting point was to get the full contract. It took them more than a week to get the contract because the hand-over from previous contracting parties to my client’s company had not been done correctly. Contract in hand, I started reading it. I read it a number of times, made notes and then met with my client to ask them a few questions. For example; how many devices did they have, what generation of devices did they have, who/when was the invoices paid, can I have access to their on-line billing service to verify costs, etc. Conclusions: the contract had not been managed nor enforced by the previous owners’ contract manager/operations manager. Clause 12 stated that after x-number of devices deployed that all subsequent devices would be free of charge and that if the client went over a certain spend that there would be a reduction in unit costs. After having matched the client’s services, costs and device fleet to the contract, I advised our client, underpinned by evidence and clause extracts, that they were owed in excess of £15K in overpaid unit costs, that they were owed £10K for having paid for devices that they had to get free of charge, that their data and roaming fees were to be reduced to bring it in line with the contract terms and that their contract could be renewed at a lower price since the supplier had a special deal on for companies with their profile.

In a post devolution or M&A contract situation, it is not enough just to have a contract for key suppliers. The contract is an essential instrument which lays out what your roles and responsibilities are vis à vis your counter-part. In the case of Novated Contracts, the two parties need to meet and confirm that the requirements, pricing, payment terms, etc are still correctly captured and if not, that changes are made right away. It was only when my client’s company was having service issues that they decided to dust off this document and look into it. Novated Contracts with your third party suppliers need to get your special attention. For if, like in this case, the contract made provision for volume and other discounts, these would not have been claimed if we did not look at this contract. Service failures, which was not in the original contract could have been inserted in the Novated contract, but in this case was missing until we included it.

All in all, the cost of our services to our client was £1K. The client, through our help received a check for £25K with additional cost reduction for the next 3 years of the new contract. It pays to know what your contract says.
  • Contract Negotiation
  • Supplier Mannagement
  • Contract Management
  • Supplier Negotiation
  • Outsourcing

We are a Global Procurement, Supply Chain and Business Consultancy specialising in Supplier Vetting and Management, Business Analytics, Business Interpretation and Translations, Contracts Management,…


do you need video/photo content?

Do you need video and photo content to market your brand or organisation?ever bought something online without viewing a…
Marketing & PR

Why Blog Anyway?

Blogs are great for your business' online presence. I could end this entry right there because that sums everything up…
Retail & Services

Delta Mesh Chairs for the home ( or the workplace)

If you are still working at home or in fact being asked to go back into the office, then make sure that you have a good…

More Articles


Mitigating Inheritance Tax

Inheritance tax (IHT) is payable on death or at certain stages during lifetime. For the purposes of this article we…
Financial Services

What’s the difference between saving and investing?

From an early age, we’re used to the idea of saving up for something special. We have piggy banks to incentivise us…
Information Technology

Does your company do something innovative?

Hello! We are Counting King R&D Consultants and we are on the hunt for Manchester based businesses who have creating…

Would you like to promote an article ?

Post articles and opinions on Manchester Professionals to attract new clients and referrals. Feature in newsletters.
Join for free today and upload your articles for new contacts to read and enquire further.

Find the right professionals in Manchester

View The Full Index

Search By:

Submit your Enquiry here

Enquiry Details

Contact Details